Maybe the tens of millions of people living in New York aren't Microsoft's target market, because we have yet to speak to an NYC apartment dweller who has not had to clamber over their sofa to set up the Kinect and you can forget about playing many of the multiplayer games. Not to overemphasize this point, but the rigid space requirements for setting up and using the Kinect are incredibly annoying.
Scott: The Wii is the most forgiving of the motion systems in terms of space, and the easiest to set up; all you need to do is attach a sensor bar, and even the Wii Fit board is self-contained.
It's the best system for playing in cramped quarters, such as a dorm room or kid's bedroom. The Move is more complicated because it also requires a camera to be installed near the TV, which won't actually be used for most PS3 games. It requires a few feet of distance to use, but most games only register the controller's motion, not yours there are a few exceptions.
The Kinect, once installed, is controller- and hassle-free, but it's also the most high-maintenance of them all to set up properly. Lighting and ambient noise need to be perfect, and your whole living room belongs to the Kinect's playspace, since your whole body is utilized in many Kinect launch games. Dan: Microsoft's Kinect has yet to really distinguish itself in the short list of launch games , so it seems unfair to judge it too prematurely although the early examples seem to leave so-called "core" gamers out in the cold.
The Move offers, in my hands-on testing, the best one-to-one control over a game , and the most realistic interaction. The Wii MotionPlus has largely closed the performance gap, but many Wii owners will stick with the original hardware. The Wii ecosystem wins hands down for the sheer number and scope of games, but it seemed a lot more impressive before all the competition came on the scene.
Scott: The Wii has a clear advantage with the greatest software lineup, but many of the best Wii games don't really use motion all that much, and extra peripherals such as the Wii Fit board and the little-used but now integrated MotionPlus technology add up and begin to feel a little gimmicky.
It's too early to tell on the Move and Kinect, but so far their games have been a little lackluster and unoriginal, although they're far better produced and feature stronger graphics.
A few winners have emerged for both platforms, but they're few and far between. Dan: By this, we mean how likely is this device to end up collecting dust in a closet? That's a common complaint about the Wii: After the initial rush wears off, many Wii consoles end up in semi-retirement. It kind of is, but so much more powerful.
That means you can move the controller side-to-side, forward and back and every which way. Simply put, the Playstation Move is all about games where Kinect feels like something more. It feels like Microsoft is on the verge of something really big and is using its Xbox gaming platform as a sandbox for the motion tracking system.
Sony is a hardware company first where Microsoft has primarily been in only software. Sony wants to sell you your whole entertainment system from the TV to the speakers to the gaming system and media playback devices. Microsoft wants to connect your world with Windows, Windows Phone 7 and Xbox Both Sony and Microsoft have developed their motion control system with these goals in mind. To quote the outspoken Playstation spokesman, Kevin Butler,.
Motions that both the Wii Motion Plus and Move pick up so well. The Kinect requires a lot of exaggeration, something that kids have a hard time getting when they have been used to precision in gaming and you've been telling them for years to "stop spazzing out.
While a lot of parents seem concerned about the Wii remote getting flung into the television screen, I would implore those parents to just tighten the strap. Same deal for the Move. Plus, you can teach your kids that all it takes is a flick of the wrist for most movements in the games, not a complete body attack.
Mixing movement with buttons helps to improve hand-eye coordination and is a great transition into the future of gaming, which will probably be all movement. I'd say that the Wii Motion Plus or the Move would be a better choice for younger kids at this point. One of the concepts with the Kinect that I found hard explaining to the children and having them follow the concept is they don't have to keep jumping and creeping towards the television set.
You think worrying about a child flinging Wii remote at the television is bad? This is a concept that, thankfully, most adults understand. The range of the Kinect, if the sensor is placed correctly, is perfect for most adults and most motions within the scope of the games are picked up. You still have to have a clear room, and the game goes bonkers whenever your kids walk in front of you which, if you have any, is often. The Kinect offers the best movement for adults looking to get fit.
While the Wii and the Move have fitness offerings, you are still holding a controller in your hand and the impulse to be lazy with it is hard to avoid. The real kicker here is going to be if and how the Kinect does first person shooters. Both the Wii and the Move have guns. With those guns, you can shoot things on screen. Using the controller snapped into the rifle attachment, it took some getting used to, but it was pretty freaking awesome. That is a huge selling point for adult gamers.
I'm thinking the Kinect is going to have to do something similar, as shooting with a pretend gun isn't as fun as say, playing air guitar. Because of the first person shooter aspect I don't even want to think about how any of the systems are going to handle an RPG such as Skyrim with motion controls I have to give this category to the Wii and the Move. Mostly the Move because the games are better on the Playstation vs.
I'm sure the next iteration of the Wii will have HD, but right now it doesn't. The game selection is one of the most important factors when purchasing a new system. Where the Move and the Kinect have specific games that use those tools, every single game for the Wii uses motion controls.
Of course, some of them use them better than others. The motion controls when applied to games such as Zelda: Skyward Sword are clunky and confusing. The game is much better served with a classic controller. Of course, it's not a great game to begin with, so there is that. Of course, there is Mario. They make perfect use of the motion controls and have the longstanding nostalgic value to go with them.
Still, though, the best game I've ever played on the Wii is golf, and I hate golf in real life, so that's saying something. The Move has a pretty moderate selection of games, including shooters and games for the whole family.
0コメント